“a market priced at 50% resolves yes only 32% of the time”
Manifold and Polymarket are both biased toward "something happens", and the sign of the error flips with the question's default. Where nothing happening resolves NO, a market priced at 50% on Manifold resolved YES just 32% of the time — a 2.1x overprice, versus 40% and 1.5x on Polymarket. Where nothing happening resolves YES, the bias reverses. Still, AUROC of 0.87 and 0.91 says prices rank outcomes well.
Some technical background helpful
Platforms mentioned: Manifold, Polymarket